Saturday, April 28, 2018

Shadowbanning - Mere Censorship or A Tangent Toward Stalinism?

I begin this blog knowing full well that posting it on Twitter with its title alone may result in my Twitter account getting shadowbanned; I post it with a real concern that it may get my Twitter account actually banned. But someone who is genuinely concerned with truth, with speaking out for what is just and right, and with not allowing totalitarianism to stand in the way of their passions and ideals cannot let such worries hold them back, and I don't intend to.

Once upon a time, those who brought up shadowbanning, save for small cluster groups, were generally mocked as conspiracy theorists or as paranoid. That Twitter couldn't or wouldn't do such a thing. Then it began happening more and more frequently until we have reached the point that 2018 has been dubbed the Year of the Shadowban.

People are being shadowbanned left and right, often for the most ridiculous forms of wrongthink - such as a chronic pain advocate [Edit: He has since had his shadowban lifted] who backed up his tearing apart of the myth of prescription opioids being the crux of the opioid crisis with fact, data and research. Yes, how dare he call attention to what four researchers from the CDC have already stated in a paper they published.

I digress.

For those rare individuals who are unfamiliar with it, Shadowbanning is what I refer to as a 'soft ban.' Your tweets don't show up in tweet threads, they show as 'tweet unavailable' if you had previously been quoted, and your Twitter interactions go completely without notifications to those you're interacting with - and the only way anyone can actually see your tweets is to go directly to your profile and hit tweets and replies.

Typically, shadowbanning is done to people who have committed the unholy crime of wrongthink - they have an opinion that Twitter does not want them to have, but their infraction [Edit:Typo of "infarction" corrected. Thanks mom LOL] isn't strictly against the terms of service. Twitter and Jack continue to deny it is happening.

The message they're sending is very simple: You will think how they tell you to think, you will have the opinions they tell you to have, you will read the content they've decided you can read, and anything that's divergent will be censored. Plain and simple it is a Stalinist-level form of censorship that only grows as more and more people are shadowbanned.

So, the big question is: What can we do about it? The answer to that question in itself presents a problem of sorts, because it's an answer that is unlikely to occur.

The answer is to organize a large-scale boycott of sorts; to have a massive number of people stop using Twitter for a week or more. Hurt their profits, and they might actually start listening to us.

Until then, Twitter will continue to police our thoughts, censor our speech, and silence any who dissent from what is "right."

In no free society can censorship of speech exist. Even hate speech must have a platform; if hate speech is forbidden, it doesn't stop. It simply moves into the shadows, where it is spoken in secret to those vulnerable to its influence, and where it has no opposition. Out in the open, those vulnerable to the influence of hate speech will hear the opposing arguments of those standing up against it, and fighting for what's right. Only in the light can hate speech be conquered.

Censorship stops nothing. It only moves what was censored into hiding where it grows in the shadows.

Standing up against censorship isn't something that's just an idle thought. It's something that must - must! - be done if freedom and liberty are to flourish.

No comments:

Post a Comment